Dog Breeding Methods for Beginners
By: Responsible Group Australia Posted July 24, 2023
The practice of dog breeding requires careful decision-making, taking into account various factors such as genetics, health, breed traits, and the like. One of the most pivotal decisions for a breeder is the choice of breeding method. Whether you’re breeding an Alaskan Malamute or a German Shorthaired Pointer, you’ll have to make the choice that’s best for your dog, your future puppies, and for the health of the breed.
Natural Mating vs Artificial Insemination
Natural Breeding
Natural breeding, also known as live cover or natural mating, is the traditional method where a male and a female dog mate without human intervention.
The key advantage of natural breeding is its relatively lower cost compared to artificial insemination, primarily due to the absence of medical procedures or specialised equipment.
However, natural breeding is not without its drawbacks. There is an inherent risk of dogs inflicting injuries on each other during the process. Logistical challenges also exist, given that natural breeding requires the physical presence of both dogs in the same location, a factor that could be problematic for international or cross-country breedings.
Artificial Insemination
Artificial insemination (AI) is a procedure where semen, manually collected from a male dog, is inserted into the reproductive tract of a female dog by a skilled veterinarian or breeder.
AI eliminates the need for both dogs to be in the same place at the same time, making it easier for breeders to access a wider gene pool. Semen can be collected, chilled, or frozen, and then shipped to the location of the female dog. Safety is another crucial benefit, as AI minimises the risk of injury to either dog during breeding. AI also allows breeders to control the exact timing of insemination, which can increase the chances of a successful pregnancy, especially in breeds with shorter or less predictable fertility windows.
Nonetheless, AI is not free from potential downsides. The cost of AI can be substantial, particularly for advanced methods like trans-cervical or surgical insemination, coupled with the additional costs of semen collection, preservation, and shipping. Certain studies have indicated that AI, particularly using frozen semen, might have lower success rates than natural breeding. It’s also important to note that AI demands a certain level of expertise, or the aid of a trained veterinarian, to ensure the safety of the procedure.
Which Method Should You Choose
Choosing between natural breeding and artificial insemination largely depends on the individual circumstances of the breeder and the dogs involved.
Physical characteristics of certain breeds can sometimes make natural mating challenging, thereby making AI a more feasible option. For instance, crossing breeds with size disparities often benefits from AI. However, if financial constraints are a major consideration, natural breeding is typically the more economical choice.
Whether you opt for natural breeding or artificial insemination, your decision should be governed by what’s best for the health and well-being of the dogs and the long-term vitality of the breed. Collaborating with a reputable veterinarian or reproduction specialist can help clarify all your options and assist in making the most appropriate choice for your breeding program.
It’s imperative to remember that responsible breeding goes beyond the method of conception and includes health testing, careful consideration of the temperament and physical traits of the dogs, and the assurance of secure homes for all the puppies that are born.
RPBA expects that all its members will be well-versed in breeding, helping ensure that our members are contributing to the goal of ethical treatment for all pets, regardless of breed.
Join Our Community
When getting your pet from an RPBA breeder, you will get access to the following RPBA buyer discounts:
